I had no idea this was happening. Honestly, it’s unsettling. This post exists because I finally asked a question. You know how you know something’s off? Nothing urgent, just… off? And you shrug it off, keep it moving? That was me with butter. Over the past five or six years, I’ve noticed it doesn’t melt like it used to. I thought I was imagining things — maybe it wasn’t at room temp long enough, maybe the toast wasn’t hot enough. Then, last week, I finally asked. And here we are.
In recent years, people have noticed that butter, including grass-fed and organic varieties, doesn’t soften as readily at room temperature as it used to. Butter’s changing. It’s not softening at room temperature, even the grass-fed and organic varieties. Canada calls it “Buttergate,” and the culprit is palm oil derivatives in cattle feed.
The role of palm oil in dairy farming
To enhance milk production, farmers add palm oil or its byproducts, like palm fatty acid distillate (PFAD), to cow feed. PFAD is a co-product of palm oil refining. While palmitic acid is present in all fat sources, making its complete removal from dairy feed impossible, cows’ mammary glands naturally regulate fatty acid transfer, limiting the amount that ends up in milk fat.
Farmers use palm oil in dairy feed because its high palmitic acid content increases butterfat percentages, while its energy density provides essential dietary fat for high-producing cows.
Impact on butter consistency
Butter’s altered texture is a direct result of palm oil in cow feed. Specifically, higher levels of palmitic acid can increase the melting point of butter, resulting in a firmer texture that’s less spreadable at room temperature. This change has been particularly noted in Canada, where consumers reported that butter had become harder and less likely to soften at ambient temperatures.
Industry response and consumer concerns
After these concerns surfaced, the Dairy Farmers of Canada (DFC) asked producers to pause the use of palm oil supplements in cattle feed. The goal was to reassure consumers and uphold trust in dairy products. The association also established a working group to study fat supplementation in the dairy industry. Though “Buttergate” is a Canadian controversy, what about us, the U.S. dairy industry?
Is this a widespread practice in the U.S.?
While less publicized in the U.S. than in Canada, palm oil derivatives are present in American livestock feed. Some large dairy operations incorporate them for economic efficiency. But concerns over sustainability and consumer preferences have led some farmers to seek alternative fat sources, such as flaxseed, soybeans, or canola oil.
Unlike Canada, where the DFC hit pause on palm oil in feed back in 2021, there’s no big push for that in the U.S. Some American dairy brands skip palm oil-based feed on their own, aiming to keep their butter in line with what consumers see as “natural” or “traditional.”
Balancing production and quality
While palm oil supplements can increase milk fat production, they also raise concerns about the nutritional profile and physical characteristics of dairy products. The increased firmness of butter due to higher saturated fat content may not align with consumer expectations for spreadability and texture. Plus, the use of palm oil in animal feed has broader environmental and ethical implications, given the controversies surrounding palm oil production.
The alteration in butter’s melting behavior underscores the complex relationship between animal feed practices and food quality. To address these challenges, the dairy industry must find a balance between efficient production, consumer desires and ethical practices.
Checking for organic or pasture-raised certifications may help determine if a specific brand or farm utilizes palm oil in their feed. As for me, I’ve been buying organic butter. I wasn’t focused on organic, pasture-raised butter. Now, I am.
This is a reminder for all of us — we need to focus on what the animal is eating. Don’t take five or six years (like I did) to ask the important questions. SMH. LOL.
Access the Bio-Nutrition Reference Collection today!
Apply 10 protocols grounded in nutrition, physiology
and mindset that deliver immediate, tangible results.
Reclaim your agency, and take control before inaction does.
You’re the boss. Holisticnutritioness.com is your partner.